The doctrine of the recognition of states
in the international legal doctrine of the classical period
(based on the research of M.A. Zimmerman
“Intervention and recognition in international law”)

Лилиана Тимченко

2020 vol. 58

The doctrine of the recognition of states in the international legal doctrine of the classical period (based on the research of M.A. Zimmerman “Intervention and recognition in international law”)

Лилиана Тимченко ¹

More details

Hide details

Факультет права и международных отношений Киевского университета имени Бориса Гринченко

Publication date: 2020-11-12

Studia Politologiczne 2020;58

Article (PDF)

References (14)

KEYWORDS

institute of recognition

M.A. Zimmermann

state

criteria of recognition

effectiveness of international law

ABSTRACT

It is difficult for researchers to explain the phenomenon of recognition of States. The author had decided to address the issue from the perspective of the doctrine of State recognition in classical international law. The basis for this work was the study of the most prolific scientist of the Russian immigration ‒ M.A. Zimmerman. The main hypothesis of the article is focused on the idea that narrow political interests of the state may be overcome only by the force of balanced collective legal decisions on the issue of recognition.

PEER REVIEW INFORMATION

Article has been screened for originality

peer-reviewed

REFERENCES (14)

J.G. Bluntschli, Das Moderne Völkerrecht der Civilisirten Staaten, Nördlingen 1868.

Google Scholar

A.M. Gorovtcev, Mezhdunarodnoe pravo. Izbrannaia literatura. Kratkaia entciklopediia, Sankt-Peterburg 1909 (А.М. Горовцев, Международное право. Избранная литература. Краткая энциклопедия, Санкт-Петербург 1909).

Google Scholar

V.E. Grabar, Materialy k istorii literatury mezhdunarodnogo prava v Rossii (1647–1917), Moskva 1958 (В.Э. Грабарь, Материалы к истории литературы международного права в России (1647–1917), Москва 1958).

Google Scholar

M.W. Janis, J.E. Noyes, Cases and Commentary on International Law, St. Paul, Minn. 1997.

Google Scholar

R.A. Kalamkarian, Mezhdunarodno-pravovoe znachenie odnostoronnikh iuridicheskikh aktov gosudarstv, Moskva 1984 (Р.А. Каламкарян, Международно-правовое значение односторонних юридических актов государств, Москва 1984).

Google Scholar

L. Kamarovskii, Osnovnye voprosy nauki mezhdunarodnogo prava, Moskva 1895 (Л. Камаровский, Основные вопросы науки международного права, Москва 1895).

Google Scholar

S.A. Melnik, Odnostoronnie akty gosudarstva v sovremennom mezhdunarodnom prave, Odessa 2011 (С.А. Мельник, Односторонние акты государства в современном международном праве, Одесса 2011).

Google Scholar

A. Merezhko, Russkaia nauka mezhdunarodnogo prava v period Pervoi mirovoi voiny, Odessa 2014 (А.А. Мережко, Русская наука международного права в период Первой мировой войны, Одесса 2014).

Google Scholar

L. Oppenheim, International law: a treatise, London 1920, Vol. 1.

Google Scholar

10.

I. Rogalevich, Kratkii kurs po mezhdunarodnomu pravu, Sankt-Peterburg 1902 (И. Рогалевич, Краткий курс по международному праву, Санкт-Петербург 1902).

Google Scholar

11.

W. Schücking, H. Wehberg, Die Satzung des Völkerbundes, R.G. 1921.

Google Scholar

12.

E. Von Ullmann, Das offentliche Recht der Gegenwart, Tübingen 1908.

Google Scholar

13.

F. Williams, Recognition, «Transactions of the Grotius Society» 1929, Vol. 15.

Google Scholar

14.

M.A. Zimmerman, Vmeshatelstvo i priznanie v mezhdunarodnom prave, Praga 1926 (М.А. Циммерман, Вмешательство и признание в международном праве, Прага 1926).

Google Scholar

Instructions for authors